In Review: ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping,’ ‘Elsinore,’ ‘Minotaur’

A 'Hunger Games' prequel leads a batch of new releases that include the true story of an against-the-odds theatrical performance and a cutting Russian thriller.

In Review: ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping,’ ‘Elsinore,’ ‘Minotaur’

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Dir. Francis Lawrence
158 min.

Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes, Glenn Close, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Jason Schwartzman, Peter Dinklage, Viola Davis. Julianne Moore, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Jeffrey Wright, Stanley Tucci, Donald Sutherland. These are some of the actors who have cycled through the last few entries in The Hunger Games franchise, and have had their time more or less wasted doing them, even if they’ve mostly acquitted themselves well in the roles. Based on Suzanne Collins’ popular YA books, the series peaked with the second film, Catching Fire, and sputtered through an arc with Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen, whose time in a televised death match turned her into the reluctant figurehead of a revolution. Now the franchise has turned to prequels to fill the backstory, first with 2023’s The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, about the origins of Panem’s diabolical leader, Coriolanus Snow, and now Sunrise on the Reaping, about the year Haymitch Abernathy, Katness’ hard-drinking mentor, won the Games. Once again, the casts seem to be getting better as the material gets thinner. 

SPONSORED

We hope you're enjoying these reviews but The Reveal has much more than reviews to offer. Become a paid subscriber and you'll get access to everything we publish—from articles to lists to audio commentaries—and help support independent film criticism.

Become a paid subscriber!

After taking over the series with Catching Fire—Gary Ross directed the first movie—Francis Lawrence has brought a sleek continuity to the dystopian world of Panem that now seems more like a template, despite the variations in the arenas and in the evolving authoritarianism of Panem itself. Sunrise on the Reaping is, then, exactly the film you’d expect it to be, a crisply staged sci-fi adventure that checks in on familiar characters, gives a new set of A+ actors room to cook, and plants the seeds of the popular rebellion to come. It’s all credibly done, but the rationale for each new hero keeps getting thinner: Katniss’ journey from humble tribute to rabble-rousing icon carried the original Hunger Games and multiple sequels (to a degree), and Snow’s villain trajectory in The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes accounts for the coarsening of his soul. But is it really worth knowing how Haymitch developed a drinking problem? 

Okay, that’s a little glib, but Sunrise on the Reaping doesn’t do enough to justify filling in this piece of the backstory. One significant problem is that Haymitch’s story mirrors Katniss’ nearly beat-for-beat, starting with a reaping where he enters the deadly competition without his name being drawn. On his birthday, the 16-year-old Haymitch (Joseph Zada, a complete zero) dutifully turns up for the District 12 lottery to choose which children are selected for the Games. In celebration of the 50th anniversary, dubbed the Second Quarter Quell, Snow (Fiennes) and the game makers are doubling the participants to four from each district. After the ceremony turns violent, Haymitch is corralled along with three other “tributes,” most notably Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), a like-aged girl whose hostility makes her a wild card for Haymitch and the Capitol alike. 

The prequel gives Lawrence the opportunity to cast younger versions of important characters and they’re all aces, including an underused Fiennes as a glowering Snow, Culkin as the flamboyantly sinister emcee Caesar Flickerman, Elle Fanning as the cheery stylist Effie Trinket, and Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, the future gamemaker and saboteur that Hoffman played in the Mockingjay movies. (Down the cast list, Maya Hawke, Kelvin Harrison Jr., and Lily Taylor turn up in roles once played by Amanda Plummer, Wright, and Lynn Cohen, respectively.) The arena in Sunrise on the Reaping turns out to be a deadlier adversary than the expanded field of competitors, especially once Haymitch resolves to fight through the mechanized flora and fauna that are keeping him from throwing a wrench in the Capitol’s killing machine. 

We know that Haymitch does not succeed in overthrowing the Capitol, and that the true victory is many years ahead, since Katniss is barely a gleam in her parents’ eyes at this point. That gives a certain dramatic weight to the closing minutes of Sunrise on the Reaping, when his Pyrrhic victory comes with an immediate cost that will not produce dividends until well into the future. But again, all of this is known from the original Hunger Games movies, which inherently lowers the stakes. There’s no more story to tell, just supplemental material. — Scott Tobias

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens today in districts everywhere.

Elsinore
Dir. Simon Stone
111 min.

Ian Charleson (Andrew Scott) doesn’t have any trouble getting recognized, it’s just not always the sort of recognition he wants. When strangers figure out he’s one of two leads of the Best Picture-winning 1981 film Chariots of Fire, it doesn’t take long for them to start humming the Vangelis theme song. But, as the ’80s rolled on, the film career he’d hoped to have has failed to materialize and now, at the end of the decade, he’s pretty sure the theme will endure, but not the film, much less his performance. Ian seems sanguine about this, but for troubling reasons. Only his closest friends, like casting director Patsy Pollock (Billie Piper), know he’s HIV positive. And though, as the film opens, he remains asymptomatic, Ian knows how his story will end and that the end isn’t too far away. 

When he develops his first lesion, while shooting an action film with dialogue so silly he couldn’t get through his screen test without laughing, he’s filled with a desire to return to the stage—an urge that coincides with Daniel Day-Lewis walking off a National Theatre performance of Hamlet mid-performance. But after Ian falls ill during rehearsals, his doctor Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman, playing a real-life figure who helped pioneer HIV treatment in the U.K.) warns him that pursuing the strenuous role will almost certainly shorten his life.

Just as Ian is motivated by the certainty of a short life, that plot description suggests how Elsinore will end as well, especially if you know that in real-life Charleson died in 1990 at the age of 40, mere weeks after his final performance of Hamlet. You can probably even guess many of the beats Elsinore will hit along the way, particularly given that Scott, screenwriter Stepehn Beresford, and director Simon Stone have cited inspirational sports movies like Rocky and The Karate Kid as influences. 

But while Elsinore has a few moments that tug a bit too hard at the heartstrings, the film skillfully acknowledges and usually carefully navigates through the expected moments by maintaining a reflective, bittersweet tone, a strain of dark humor, and, above all (and appropriately), a reliance on the abilities of its actors. You might expect there to be a difficult hospital scene involving Charleson and his parents (Georgie Glen and Peter Mullan), but it’s one made devastatingly effective by the care taken in staging and playing it.

Even actors given only a handful of scenes make them count, like Luke Thompson as an old lover whose condition worsens before Ian’s and Joe Locke as a younger patient in Margaret’s ward who might have been more to Ian under different circumstances. David Dawson’s memorable, too, as director Derek Jarman, who’s grown semi-estranged with Ian. He’s initially angry that Ian’s remained in the closet and erased one of Jarman’s early films from his resumé, then later pushes him to go public with his AIDS diagnosis, which Ian resists doing. 

In the end, however, this is Scott’s movie, and his restrained, heartbreaking performance is what makes it so moving. In early scenes, Ian seems a bit like a ghost, walking through London’s gay nightlife but keeping his distance when chances for intimacy present themselves. This was once his world but now it belongs to others. Later he’ll stroll a popular cruising spot not for sex but to seek out the advice of two members of the Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence (Dickie Beau and Kadiff Kirwan), AIDS activists who don nuns’ habits to distribute free condoms. Scott plays Ian as a man who understands he has a limited time to take care of any unsettled business, from playing Hamlet to patching up old relationships. He goes about it all with much determination but little outward urgency (and in sharp contrast to his forceful work as Hamlet). If the film around him occasionally makes the connections between Ian’s story and the ways Shakespeare addresses the same big questions he’s facing too obvious, Scott’s work keeps it grounded. He emphasizes the immediate experience of a man who refuses to let a last chance to do what he feels he was born to do pass him by, one determined (to paraphrase different play) to make his strutting and fretting upon the stage mean something before it can be heard no more. —Keith Phipps

Elsinore opens in limited release tonight before expanding.

Minotaur
Dir. Andrey Zvyagintsev 
142 min.

In a scene from Andrey Zvyagintsev’s ice-cold, politically loaded crime drama Minotaur, three executive types from a provincial Russian city excuse themselves from their glamorous partners and step outside a high-end restaurant for cigarettes. The topic under discussion is an ultimatum given to them by the government, which needs men to fight the new war with Ukraine: Either they can discreetly choose who goes into military service or agents can take the choice out of their hands, so long as the quota is met. Though there’s some consternation over the decision, their main concern seems to relate to a disruption of the business, rather than the fate of their soon-to-be-ex employees. One of them announces his plan to jet off to Thailand for vacation until the smoke clears. He isn’t wracked with guilt over what he needs to do, exactly, but it just seems to make him a little uncomfortable. 

The second film inspired by Claude Chabrol’s 1969 thriller The Unfaithful Wife—the first was Adrian Lyne’s Unfaithful, with Richard Gere and Diane Lane—Minotaur is a nasty tale of infidelity and murder, but Zvyagintsev connects it pointedly to oligarchical privilege. After establishing himself as one of Russia’s most exciting filmmakers with similar slow-burn exercises like The Return, Elena, Loveless, and Leviathan, Zvyagintsev has been missing in action for nine years, during which time he nearly died of COVID-19 and opted to live in exile in France due to his opposition to the Ukraine invasion. Minotaur is a shot across the bow, operating both as a suspense film about crimes of passion and a commentary on who does (and does not) have to sacrifice themselves for war. The two agendas would seem to be hard to reconcile, but both are about getting away with murder. 

First seen in their luxurious home in the country, where they’re raising a normal adolescent boy, Gleb (Dmitriy Mazurov) and his beautiful wife Galina (Iris Lebedeva) have entered into a daily routine where he goes off to work as the CEO of a shipping company and she heads into town, ostensibly to run errands and make appointments. Gleb suspects infidelity and a private investigator confirms that she’s having an affair with Anton (Yuriv Zavalnyouk), a dashing young photographer who’s become a refuge from her suffocating, sexless marriage. 

Though Gleb has also been guilty of sleeping around, he nonetheless pays Anton a visit at his apartment and their brief conversation takes an inevitably nasty turn. Zvyagintsev leaves it up to the viewer to decide whether Gleb acts out of jealousy or entitlement, but Minotaur is shrewdly constructed to suggest some ugly combination of the two. Zvyagintsev has directed Hitchcockian material before—it’s fitting that he’d turn to Chabrol, a slavishly devoted Hitchcock acolyte on par with Brian De Palma—but by making Gleb’s elevated social status in Russia part of the story, he changes a crime of passion into a show of elite corruption. The most masterful stretch of the film comes after Gleb’s encounter with Anton, when his mistakes would seem to point to a slow unraveling, but Russian politics are a formidable counter for noir plot mechanics. The difference between the haves and have-nots are those who give their lives and those who can take them. — Scott Tobias

Minotaur opens in New York and Los Angeles this weekend and expands from there.

Discussion