Monkey Trouble in ‘The Right Stuff’

With a new Criterion edition, 'The Right Stuff' takes its place among the great films about space travel.

Monkey Trouble in ‘The Right Stuff’

“The issue here ain’t pussy. The issue here is monkey.” 

That’s Gus Grissom (Fred Ward), the least articulate of the Mercury Seven astronauts in The Right Stuff, making a gruff haiku out of a problem that’s been dogging these accomplished pilots from the start. Though NASA has chosen them from a pool of over 50 elite military applicants, the cold truth is that human beings are not needed for this early stage of space travel, when the risks are extraordinary and the contributions of a human pilot are virtually nil. Their recruitment and training had nothing to do with their stick-work or aerial maneuvers, but more simply their capacity to endure the bodily stress of being strapped to a rocket and jettisoned to the heavens. Grissom’s terse remarks come after John Glenn (Ed Harris), a squeaky-clean idealist with an all-too-apparent future in politics, scolds the men for skirt-chasing the evening before, which he sees as a distraction from the mission. Now they can have it out over what, exactly this mission is all about. 

The bottom line: Not only could a monkey do their jobs, but a monkey would be the optimal choice, because the consequences of a fiery catastrophe are obviously much lower and the animal’s intellectual limitations are an asset. But the Soviets had already accomplished a major first by sending Yuri Gagarin into space, and NASA needed humans to keep up and secure public support. Though Grissom needs interpreters to expand on his “the issue here is monkey” assessment, the conclusion is that they have to leverage their celebrity power to force NASA to adapt to them. In the very next scene, in fact, they balk at a space capsule that doesn’t have so much as a window for them to gawk at wonders that no other person has seen. The engineers are still thinking of them as “monkey,” and they threaten to go to the press if they don’t at least get a window and a hatch with explosive bolts in case they need an emergency exit. 

In her review of The Right Stuff, Pauline Kael memorably referred to the astronauts as “Henry Luce’s walking apple pies,” a nod to the Life magazine editor whose profiles epitomized NASA’s successful campaign to make All-American heroes out of human laboratory experiments. Working from Tom Wolfe’s book, which he adapted after tossing out an earlier draft by the celebrated screenwriter William Goldman (Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid), writer-director Philip Kaufman accomplishes a tone that’s somehow both reverent and down-to-earth, where you recognize these men as unwitting propagandists while appreciating them as special and actually worthy of the awe manufactured around them. Though it’s hard to understand why The Right Stuff was a box-office disappointment at the time, perhaps it’s connected to the nuance that Kaufman (and Wolfe) were trying to express. The film was going to give audiences seven walking apple pies—and with guys like Ward, Harris, Scott Glenn, and Dennis Quaid playing them, they’re still delicious—but they’d have to watch those pies get made, too, out of flour and mush. They weren’t getting the Life magazine version. 

Premium Content

This post is for paying members only

Sign up now to read the post and get access to the full library of posts for subscribers only.

✦  Sign up Already have an account? Sign in